Buy Property with EMI or Rent and Invest in mutual funds?
Savit Chaurdhary
Savit Chaurdhary
Wednesday 20 Nov 2024
  • dp
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • dp




One of the biggest decisions people often make is whether to purchase a property and pay monthly EMI or invest in mutual funds while staying on rent. There are strengths and weaknesses of each of the mentioned approaches. Here we discuss what each of the options can provide to assist you in making the appropriate choice.


Option 1: Buying a Property and Paying EMIs


Many people are driven by a desire to own a home since this is not only necessary but is also leads to an investment whose value appreciates. It does so to the detriment of long-term liabilities that should also be accounted for.


Pros of Buying a Property


  • Building Equity: All the EMI means creates ownership in your property, and you are constantly adding to your net worth. Eventually, houses and other forms of property increase in value, and this makes it good business if, for instance, you choose to sell the house.

  • Tax Benefits: The house loan borrowers in India are privileged to get exemptions on both the principal and interest amount of the home loan under section 80C and section 24-b of the Income Tax Act. Most times, these tax benefits bring down your EMI Irration and pass on an added value to the experience of owning a home.

  • Long-Term Stability: A home provides stability, something quite important for those who own it especially if they have families or if they prefer to remain in one area of the country. You will not be evicted and will not have to be moved frequently, thus relying on concrete foundations, not the landlords.


Cons of Buying a Property


  • Financial Strain of EMIs: Overhead charges of EMIs for housing tend to swamp a good chunk of incomes thereby limiting disposable income for other projects or investments. High EMI obligations can restrict the choice of lifestyle and manage financial performance.

  • Maintenance and Upkeep: The added cost in home ownership includes issues such as repair costs, property taxes, and insurance fees to name but a few; these are cumulative and could at one point affect returns to homeowners.


Option 2: Investing in Mutual Funds and Living on Rent


Purchasing mutual funds during rent helps in gaining high and diversified returns besides being liquid and is suitable for those people who prefer mobility.

Advantages of Directing Investment to Mutual Fund and Renting


  • Higher Potential Returns: Equity mutual funds have been giving returns between 10-15 % in the long run and are sometimes ahead of real estate investments in metros. It may be the best form of investment for accelerating growth and using compounding to create wealth.

  • Lower Initial Cost: As we have indicated, renting is much cheaper in terms of an initial capital outlay than putting up a property since you do not pay down payments, registration fees, or stamp duty. Capital that is preserved can be invested in with high returns meaning more capital is being freed up for an individual.

  • Flexibility and Mobility: Representatives say it affords better mobility since one is free to shift based on job demands or lifestyle factors call for it, all without having to sell a property or pay an EMI.


Disadvantages of Investing in Mutual Funds and Renting


  • No Property Ownership: Monthly payments are made in rent which are just mere fractional installations of the value for which you do not own any appreciating property. As the wealth stacks up, you are still in the rental bracket with no certainty of owning a home someday.

  • Uncertain Rental Costs: Rent can go up after sometimes and this means an addition to monthly expenses given if rental prices have gone up.


Comparing Financial Outcomes: EMIs vs. Mutual Fund Investments


Let’s take an example. To make it easy to explain, let’s assume you have only 50,000 INR to spend per month. Here’s how this amount might work under each option:


  • Option 1: Ability to afford INR 50,000 EMI on property: The property owner slowly earns his or her equity, and additional appreciation to ranges of between 5-8 percent could be obtained within 20 years. The advantages of taking a loan are that by the time of the repayment of the loan, you own an asset that could have been appreciated.

  • Option 2: Investing INR 50,000 in mutual funds while renting: While renting a house for a hundred and fifty units, investing just fifty thousand units in mutual funds that yield 10 – 12% returns is surely beneficial. However, you will not have the ownership of a property but you will have the capacity to build up a great deal of liquid investment capacity to be used for other investments or lifestyle differences.


Final Thoughts

Whether to purchase a house while continuing to rent a unit depends on individual financial status, tolerance for losses, and income expected as well as the person’s lifestyle. There is equity and stability in home ownership while in mutual funds investments have higher returns and are more flexible. Some people prefer to combine owning property and investing and that varies depending on each person’s vision and life plans.



ADVERTISEMENT